Foo Fighters ‘But Here We Are’ (Review): A Triumph Over Tragedy

Readers like you help support Tony Reviews Things. When you make a purchase using links on my site, I may earn an affiliate commission. To learn more, please read our Affiliate Disclosure.
Featured Image for the post, "Foo Fighters But Here We Are (Review): A Triumph Over Tragedy"

In the world of rock, few bands have consistently delivered the goods like the Foo Fighters. With their 11th studio album, “But Here We Are,” the band once again proves their mettle, crafting a record that is as raw and unapologetic as it is poignant and powerful.

This album is a testament to the band’s resilience in the face of profound loss. In March 2022, the Foo Fighters lost their drummer, Taylor Hawkins, followed by the death of frontman Dave Grohl’s mother, Virginia, in August of the same year. These events have left an indelible mark on the band’s music, influencing the themes and lyrics of “But Here We Are” in profound ways.

A New Approach to Creation

What sets this album apart from the band’s previous work is the process behind its creation. For the first time in their career, the Foo Fighters wrote the lyrics before the music. This approach has resulted in a collection of songs that are deeply personal and emotionally charged, reflecting the band’s journey through grief and loss.

Grohl, who took on the role of drummer for this album, delivers a performance that is as cathartic as it is captivating. The only feature on the album is Grohl’s 17-year-old daughter, Violet, adding a layer of familial intimacy to the record. Co-produced by Greg Kurstin and the band, “But Here We Are” is a testament to the Foo Fighters’ ability to innovate and evolve, even in the face of adversity.

Themes and Lyrics: A Journey Through Grief

“But Here We Are” is a raw and unapologetic act of mourning. Every song on the album deals with death in some way, creating a narrative that is as heartbreaking as it is healing. The lyrics are filled with expressions of grief, loss, and the resolution to carry on, making for a listening experience that is as cathartic as it is captivating.

The album opens with Grohl reeling from the news of Hawkins’ passing, setting the tone for the emotional journey that follows. The final song, titled “Rest,” offers a poignant conclusion to the album. Here, Grohl sings, “Rest – you will be safe now,” a line that serves as a heartfelt farewell to his fallen bandmate and a promise to carry on in his memory.

Music and Style: A Testament to Resilience

Despite the heavy themes, the music of “But Here We Are” often contrasts with the lyrics, sticking to the Foo Fighters’ signature wall-of-guitars blueprint. There are moments of triumph and euphoria, with songs like “Rescued” and “Beyond Me” surging into anthem territory. These tracks serve as reminders of the band’s resilience, their ability to find light in the darkest of times.

The album also features some minor tweaks to the Foo Fighters’ usual style. “Hearing Voices” introduces a gothy-sounding echo, while “Show Me How” offers a hazy melody that could pass for My Bloody Valentine. These stylistic shifts add a layer of depth to the album, showcasing the band’s versatility and willingness to experiment.

Critical Reception: A Worthy Memorial

Critics have lauded “But Here We Are” as a standout in the Foo Fighters’ discography. The tunes are more polished, the dynamic shifts punchier, and the overall sound is more refined than their recent predecessors. It seems as if the desire to express something about Hawkins and to make an album that stands as a worthy memorial has given the band a fresh sense of purpose and momentum.

Notable Tracks: Career Highlights

Standout tracks like “Rescued,” “Under You,””Nothing At All,” “Beyond Me,” and “The Glass” are hard-driving career highlights that sound both timeless and utterly of the present. “Rescued,” the lead single, is an upbeat, communal rock anthem that showcases the band’s knack for crafting infectious hooks. “Under You” is a surf rock track that’s one of the most immediate songs they’ve ever released, while “Nothing At All” taps into a sleek pop groove, showcasing the band’s versatility.

“Beyond Me” pulls inspiration from Oasis’ more tender moments, offering a softer side to the Foo Fighters that fans will surely appreciate. “The Glass” is a haunting track that focuses on the comforting piece of the past, a poignant reflection on the band’s journey and the memories they’ve made along the way.


Listen to Foo Fighters – But Here We Are on Spotify

Final Thoughts: A Celebration of Brotherhood

Rating: ★★★★☆ 4/5 Stars

“But Here We Are” is more than just an album; it’s a beautiful, noisy celebration of brotherhood and a stark, painful exploration of loss. It’s messy, gut-wrenching, ambitious, and gorgeous, as the remaining members of Foo Fighters push themselves to their limits and beyond.

The album is an undeniable reminder of the healing, unifying power of music. It’s a testament to the band’s resilience, their ability to channel their grief into something beautiful and cathartic. It’s a record that is sure to resonate with fans, serving as a fitting tribute to their fallen bandmate and a powerful addition to their impressive discography.

In conclusion, “But Here We Are” is a testament to the Foo Fighters’ enduring spirit. It’s a record that captures the band at their most vulnerable and their most powerful, a poignant exploration of grief and loss that never loses sight of the hope and resilience at the heart of their music. It’s a record that proves, once again, why the Foo Fighters are one of the most beloved bands in rock music today.

In the face of adversity, the Foo Fighters have delivered an album that is as heartbreaking as it is healing, as personal as it is universal. “But Here We Are” is a record that will resonate with anyone who has experienced loss, offering a message of hope and resilience that is sure to inspire. So, here’s to the Foo Fighters, a band that continues to surprise, inspire, and rock our world. Here’s to “But Here We Are,” an album that is sure to stand as one of the band’s finest works.

Have you listened to the album yet? I’d love to hear what you think about it in the comments!

Buy Foo Fighters – But Here We Are at Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. For more information, please read our Affiliate Disclosure.
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *