Jeff’s Pizza Shop Review: Home to Iowa’s Best Calzones?

My journey to find the best calzone in Iowa took an unexpected turn when I stumbled upon Jeff’s Pizza Shop in Ames. While their mouthwatering pizza photos on Facebook initially caught my eye, it was the discovery of their ricotta-laden calzones that truly sealed the deal. After all, not every pizza place offers calzones, and even fewer make them with the creamy, dreamy goodness of ricotta cheese.

Jeff’s Pizza Shop: Fast and Friendly Delivery

Intrigued and ricotta-starved, I placed an online order at 5:30 pm, opting for delivery at 7:30 pm. To my delight, they arrived piping hot and a few minutes early—a pleasant surprise in a world of delayed deliveries. The driver was friendly and didn’t seem to mind my “starving” dog barking at him too much.

Unwrapping the aluminum foil revealed two calzones that were generously sized and visually stunning. My classic choice featured mozzarella, ricotta, and savory Italian sausage, while my fiancée, Lauren, opted for a more adventurous combination of mozzarella, ricotta, green olives, banana peppers, and pineapple.

The first bite was a pure revelation. The crust was perfectly golden brown and slightly chewy, offering the ideal combination of texture and flavor. Inside, the fillings were abundant and perfectly balanced. The mozzarella delivered its signature stretch and creamy texture, while the ricotta added a distinctive richness and tang that set Jeff’s calzones apart from the competition. The sausage in my calzone was flavorful and well-seasoned, while Lauren’s combination of sweet and savory with the pineapple and banana peppers surprisingly worked beautifully.

One of the Best Calzone’s I’ve Ever Had—and That’s Saying a Lot

It’s no exaggeration to say that this was one of the best calzones I’ve ever had, not just in Iowa but anywhere. The generous portion size, high-quality ingredients, and perfect execution resulted in a truly satisfying experience.

Beyond the calzones themselves, Jeff’s Pizza Shop offers a welcoming and convenient service. While their dining room is currently undergoing renovations (exciting news for future dine-in experiences!), they offer pickup and delivery, making it easy to enjoy their delicious creations from the comfort of your own home.

Final Verdict: Jeff’s Pizza is a Home Run!

Jeff's Pizza Shop (Ames, IA)

5 out of 5

$7.25

If you’re in Ames and looking for a delicious, satisfying calzone experience, look no further than Jeff’s Pizza Shop. You won’t be disappointed!

Calzones

5 out of 5

Delivery Service

5 out of 5

Price

5 out of 5

Pros

Phenomenal calzones

Speedy delivery

Friendly service

Fair prices

Cons

Dine-in is temporarily unavailable

Order Jeff’s Pizza Shop Online

Order Now

Here are some additional details to keep in mind when visiting Jeff’s Pizza Shop:

• Hours: Currently open for pickup and delivery only. Opening hours vary due to construction, so be sure to check their website or social media for the latest updates.
• Menu: Offers a variety of pizzas, calzones, sandwiches, and other Italian specialties. You can find the full menu on their website.
• Price: The price of the calzones is reasonable considering the generous size and quality ingredients. I paid $26.99 for the two calzones, including a $5 tip for our driver.
• Location: Located at 2420 Lincoln Way, Ames, IA 50014.

If you’re in Ames and looking for a delicious, satisfying calzone experience, look no further than Jeff’s Pizza Shop. Their ricotta-infused creations are guaranteed to leave you wanting more, making it a worthy contender for the title of “Best Calzone in Iowa.” And even if you’re not a die-hard Calzone fan, their pizzas and other menu items are sure to tempt your taste buds. So give them a try; you won’t be disappointed!

Tony Simons

Tony has a bachelor’s degree from the University of Phoenix and over 11 years of writing experience between multiple publications in the tech, photography, lifestyle, and deal industries.